Theoretically, certain things do happen when you suddenly find and talk incessantly to the crush from eighth grade, who suddenly vanished overnight in ninth to rumors of a loosely veiled cult somewhere in Missouri. You had wondered about them, it didn’t seem fair to lose someone who played bass so well, and had such long hair. You told your father one night while watching Joan of Arcadia that you would have to find them, ask them questions about God, because no one else you knew was even remotely interested. Anyway, those certain things. You’ll find them desperate, married, 3 children, awake all night with the newest, lawyering during the day. You’ll find they were in love with you, not Kaelie, and that they didn’t know you hid in the closet, clutching the landline to your cheek for so long while they spoke that it left a hot, red imprint for days. That they actually didn’t like that you dated all of their friends except them. You’ll find you listen to each other like it was still 2001, and that perhaps both of you haven’t been listened to since then. (Maybe you’re engaged to a real piece of work who’s only ambitions include shooting and killing a bear, jiu jitsu, and commercial carpentry, who won’t marry you in November because it’s hunting season, but will marry you in the freezing rains of February in a converted movie theater where you can put your names in lights for only $500 more). Maybe lines will blur, maybe your Prius will get stuck in a blizzardous snow drift outside of a nice enough hotel, where they come into your room, but you don’t let them much past the threshold, where they hold you with their body against the wall, but you don’t touch. You’ll become the catalyst for a divorce that has been surreptitiously finding its way higher and higher on their white board calendar of activities and things to do. You won’t want this, obviously, and you will protest. You’ll make them sign a blood oath that it’s not for you, because they are not for you. (By this time, your open relationship scam of an engagement will become ever increasingly nauseating, and you’ll meet Brian in a suite reserved for the wealthiest people in Minneapolis, where, sitting in a bathtub large enough for 142 inches of human body, you’ll admit (out loud) for the first and last time that you don’t love the hunter, that you never did, that it was safe, “what you do”, Midwestern. You’ll pull all your courage and leave them the following week). Probably the obvious spoiler alert is that you do end up fucking your crush from eighth grade while Nirvana’s MTV Unplugged in New York plays mellifluously in the background, and even more obvious is that you do not end up with them like people in books, but you do stay friends. Best friends, even, if you ignore the ever present undercurrent of dissatisfaction and expectancy on their end.
Theoretically.